When is a Conversion Rate Optimisation test over?

If you answered – “When Google’s website optimiser tool says it is over (with a 99% degree of statistical certainty)” then you may need to think again.

We recently ran a test on a newsletter & subscription sign up process, where the sign up required an email confirmation to complete and receive both products. The original page explained that the user had successfully signed up for the newsletter but then went on in the body of the text to say that they needed to respond to a confirmation email to complete the subscription. The variation made it clear in the headline that this was only Step 1 and made the email confirmation call to action part of the header. The test was set running and, by highlighting that the email needed to be confirmed, the variation came romping home as a winner with 99.1% chance to beat the original and more than 63% observed improvement.

conv image 1

Test after 12 hours (click image for larger version)

However the important point to note was that the variation was prompting people to respond to an email immediately. As you can imagine, those people who read the original page may not have checked their email immediately without prompting but would have checked later on – leaving a lag between the times to conversion between the two pages. Below is the screenshot after 36 hours and, as you can see, the result is no longer so clear.

conv image 2

Test after 36 hours (click image for larger version)

Although the variation is still the better page, with a 26% observed improvement, the difference between the two has been massively reduced. In this instance the variation is still almost certain to be the better page over a longer time but you can see how in closer tests this lag in conversion times could easily produce a false result.

Patience is a vital ingredient in successful testing and, although it is tempting to jump ahead when a result is being declared, it is important to be aware of elements that could skew figures and make sure you have given the test every opportunity to return a valid result.

Richard Cotton

Richard Cotton

Richard Cotton joins the team at Distilled as the Paid Search Marketer. He graduated with a Philosophy degree from Southampton University and will therefore put his analytical brain to good use as our dedicated PPC marketer. Rich C-h264720-v2 //...   read more

Get blog posts via email

0 Comments

  1. There are currently no comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*
*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>